Home Options MA(781) 483-0510

Calculators

Sell or rent your house: a calculator

Selling now turns your equity into cash you can invest. Renting keeps the house, pays you rent, and lets you sell later, but you carry taxes, insurance, upkeep, vacancy and the mortgage. This calculator compares both over the number of years you choose, using assumptions you can change. It usually comes out close, so the inputs you are least sure of (rent, growth and the investment return) deserve the most thought.

Updated November 10, 2026. Facts checked November 10, 2026 against the sources listed at the bottom. General information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Home-sale exclusion3 yearsRent it longer and you can lose the $250,000 / $500,000 exclusion (IRS Pub. 523)
Selling cost used6.5% of priceOur default: commission, excise tax and closing; change it
Landlord dutiesReal onesSecurity deposit, lead paint, smoke and CO rules in MA
Biggest swing factorGrowth and rentTry 0% and 5% growth
$
$
%
$
$

Check real listings for similar homes nearby.

$
$

Renting for more than 3 years after you move out costs you the federal home-sale exclusion. Try 4 or 5 to see the effect.

$

Used for the tax on the gain and for depreciation.

More assumptions
%
%
%

An assumption, not a forecast. Try 0% and 5% too.

%

Before tax. A savings or bond-like rate is safer than a stock-market guess.

%

After the chosen years

-

Sell nowRent, then sell

A planning comparison. This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Talk to an attorney or CPA about your situation. It ignores income tax on the rent and on investment returns, and your time. It does include a rough tax at sale: the federal home-sale exclusion applies only if you owned and lived in the home 2 of the last 5 years, which stops being true once you have rented it for more than 3 years (IRS Publication 523), and depreciation on a rental lowers your basis and is taxed when you sell at up to 25% federally, plus 5% in Massachusetts (IRS Topic 409). The tax rates are planning rates, not your return. Landlords also have legal duties in Massachusetts (security deposits, lead paint, smoke and CO alarms). See capital gains on a home sale, selling a rental and the net proceeds calculator.

How to read the comparison

Sell now: the sale price minus selling costs and your mortgage payoff, invested at the return you choose. Rent, then sell: each year's rent (less vacancy and a manager fee) minus property tax, insurance, upkeep and your mortgage payments, kept at the same return, plus the equity you have when you sell at the end (after paying selling costs).

The result is the difference in total money after the years you choose. A positive number for renting does not mean renting is safe: it assumes the house is rented without trouble, the value grows as entered and you handle repairs.

Taxes that change the answer

Being a landlord in Massachusetts

Landlords in Massachusetts hold the tenant's security deposit in a separate account and give a receipt and yearly interest (MGL c.186 s.15B), must comply with the state lead law when a child under six lives in a pre-1978 home, and must have working smoke and carbon monoxide alarms. A bad tenant is also a cost: eviction takes time and money. If you do not want that, the selling a rental guide lays out the options.

Questions

Common questions.

Is it better to sell or rent my house?

It depends on your equity, the rent compared with your carrying costs, how much the house grows and what you could earn on the cash from a sale. If rent barely covers the mortgage, taxes, insurance and upkeep, selling and investing the equity is often simpler. If rent is far above costs and you can handle being a landlord, renting can pay more over time.

Do I lose the capital gains exclusion if I rent my house?

Not right away. You need to have owned and used the house as your main home for two of the five years before the sale, so you can usually rent it for up to about three years after you move out and still sell with the exclusion. Rent depreciation is taxed separately.

What growth rate should I use?

Nobody knows. Try 0%, 3% and 5% and see whether the answer flips. If it flips, the decision rests on a guess and the safer choice is usually the one that is easier to undo.

Can I sell with a tenant in the house?

Yes. The buyer takes the house subject to the lease. See the guide to selling with tenants.

Sources

Where this comes from.

Selling? Add drone photos

Show the whole property.

Aerial photos show the lot, the yard, the roofline and the neighborhood in a way street photos cannot. Many sellers add them to a listing, and they are a short, inexpensive shoot.

See what you'd walk away with.

Enter your address. It is free, and you can stop at any point.

Free, no obligation. We show you the range before we ask for your name.

Home Options MA makes offers on houses, takes option contracts on houses, or refers owners to independent buyers and agents. If we make the offer or take the option, we are the buyer and not your agent. If we refer you, the buyer or agent may pay us a flat advertising fee, and a listing here is advertising, not a recommendation. You never pay us. No obligation.

Step 1 of 2

Where is the house?

We will show you a ballpark for your town right away. Nothing here is an appraisal, and there is no obligation.